
It’s Time to Take a Trustbuster to the NFL
Today’s National Football League has a monopolistic stranglehold on the sport that Standard Oil of the early 1900s would envy. If he were President today, Teddy Roosevelt would likely be working hard to break up the NFL. TR loved football and hated monopolies. Given that the NFL’s market dominance is partly a creature of federal legislation, a modern-day Roosevelt might start by asking Congress to repeal the special statutory protections it has afforded the league, especially the 1966 amendment to 15 U.S.C. § 1291 permitting the American Football League and the National Football League to merge into today’s unnatural behemoth. The NFL is a congressionally sanctioned monopoly.
Partly as a result, on any given Sunday-Monday-Thursday the NFL experience consists of three hours of commercials occasionally interrupted by a football game. To make matters worse, with Amazon Prime Video acquiring the national broadcasting rights to Thursday Night Football in 2022, Thursday night games generally require a paid streaming subscription: one has to pay to watch a Thursday night game while still having to sit through the commercials.
How would Teddy break up the NFL? I suspect he would pressure Congress to split the AFC and NFC back into two independent leagues.
Many of my friends have joined me in my watching habits, and I suspect many other fans do the same.
When my teams, the Bills and the Redskins (I refuse to call them the Commanders) are playing on the tube, I generally watch the first quarter with the sound muted. Then I tape the rest of the game and go do something useful with the rest of my day. When I’m good and ready, I fast forward and watch the last 10 minutes, again with the sound muted or fast forwarding through the commercials. That way, neither the league nor the sponsors make a dime off of me.
TR loved football, as did tens of thousands of Americans who watched it primarily as a college sport. Roosevelt took the lead reforming the sport amid the carnage of the 1905 season, in which as many as 25 players reportedly died and scores more were seriously injured. Many newspapers and critics called for the game to be banned, as it had been on some college campuses decades earlier. So Roosevelt dragooned coaches and college football officials at the White House, pressing them to curb the brutality that threatened the sport’s existence. The resulting reforms included the legalization of the forward pass, which opened up the game and reduced the frequency of deadly pileups. I’m convinced that TR would be appalled by the monopolistic, woke mess that the NFL has become today. The league’s eager embrace of Black Lives Matter in 2020 and its hiring of anti-Trump rapper Bad Bunny to perform in Spanish at the 2026 Super Bowl were the handiwork of effete corporate suits more concerned with political fashion statements than with the game of football.
How would Teddy break up the NFL? I suspect he would pressure Congress to split the AFC and NFC back into two independent leagues with the ability to set their own rules and shorten the games to outcompete each other for viewer interest. There would likely be a Super Bowl between the leagues with standard rules similar to today, or they might rotate league rules year-to-year.
As things stand, the fans — particularly those addicted to sports betting — have to accept whatever garbage the NFL and its sponsors deign to dish out.
If Republicans are smart — and they haven’t been lately — they will add breaking up the NFL to their 2028 platform. I think they will find an unexpected windfall of swing voters.
READ MORE from Gary Anderson:
When Generals Wander Into the Swamp
Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Warfare: Can the U.S. Military Keep Up?
What I Learned Commanding US Marines on Okinawa
Gary Anderson is a frequent contributor to TAS